To comment scroll to the bottom of the entry. Your e-mail address and URL are optional fields.


2008 06 10
Absurd Green Architecture In Dubai

image

Building in Dubai will always challenge the idea of sustainability because of the extreme temperatures and lack of water in the region. In spite of that reality, capital generated by $139 a barrel oil is making it possible for architects to try radically new, untested technologies in designs that attempt to generate more energy than they consume and in doing so achieve something that could be called sustainability.

So it is with Italian architect David Fisher’s design for the green environmental tower in Dubai. Named the “Dynamic Architecture” building, the sixty storey tower is also a power source. Forty-eight 0.3 megawatt turbines are contained within its rotating floors. Fisher writes, “Considering that Dubai gets 4,000 wind hours annually, the turbines incorporated into the building can generate 1,200,000 kilowatt-hour of energy.”

The architect describes three technologies that the project relies on for its success. First is the ability for architecture to be dynamic, to constantly change its form. Second, is the integration of power-generating technologies that let the building generate more power than its inhabitants consume. Third, is the factory-based construction that will reduce the number of site workers, speed construction time, and improve the final finish quality.

Take a look at this rather pretentious video for an explanation of the tower. What’s my take on it? Before I was an architect I followed a Buckminster Fuller inspired career path working in aircraft manufacturing for the de Havilland Aircraft Company. I’ve seen the technologies required to make this work from both sides of the technology spectrum, and odds are that this building will fail to meet its objectives. That does not mean it is an unworthy experiment. Inventing new ways of sustainable living will not be easy or cheap; however, we have little choice but to try and if it takes $139 oil to get us there so be it.


[email this story] Posted by R Ouellette on 06/10 at 10:02 AM
  1. Cool building!

    My first hope is that the building does not turn quite that fast, or those pretty interiors will be covered in vomit.

    I have doubts that this will ever get built, but Dubai is the Las Vegas of the middle-east

    Posted by Larry Lubell  on  06/25  at  05:14 PM
  2. Wow, you weren’t kidding about the “pretentious”...

    I like how each unit is supposed to have voice-activated rotation control, yet it’s not the unit that rotates, but the entire floor. So either each floor is a single apartment/condo, or the building is doomed to spontaneously combust as people simultaneously give their floor conflicting directions—or end up in fistfights over who gets to control the rotation of their floor.

    And although the video seems focused on showing off the beautiful ripple effects produced by synchronized rotating floors, in reality, that effect will never occur if each floor is independently controlled by its inhabitants. It’s funny, because no other architect would get away with such blatant misrepresentation of what their proposed building will look like once it’s built…

    Anyway, the rotating floors seems to have little to do with the wind turbines. It’s too bad they couldn’t just start with the wind turbines and make sure that it works before adding the rotation gimmick. Now if the rotation thing fails, it’s going to give the wind turbine technology a bad reputation. And given the rate that elevators, escalators, heating and air conditioning systems, etc. fail, the building is bound to have problems. I for one, would hate to live in a building that seems inevitably doomed to be a technological nightmare…

    Posted by Melissa Goldstein  on  07/04  at  01:26 AM

<< Back to main

Toronto News
Spacing
Blogto.com
CBC Toronto
Torontoist.com
Toronto Galleries



Related Links
Toronto Stories by
Stats
Toronto Links
Your Opinions


Other Blogs
News Sources
Syndicate